Mercurial Essays

Free Essays & Assignment Examples

Battle of the Books: Ethan Frome vs. Of Mice and Men

On the other hand, John Steinbeck, born on February 27, 1902, in Salinas, California spent his summers working on nearby ranches. His inspiration came from everyday life as a worker. Ethan From, the title character of Edith Wharton tragic novel Ethan Rome, lives in his own world of silence, where he replaces his scarcity of words with images and fantasies. While, on the other hand, Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck is a modern parable about the unfairness of human society. To start, many novels have different ways to appeal the reader.

For example, novels use settings, moods, tones, and many other literary parts that a reiterative needs. In Ethan From, the setting is taken place in Stratified, Massachusetts, around the late nineteenth-early twentieth century. This novel also has a different variety of tones to keep the reader from falling asleep such as foreboding, bleak, ironic, tragic, and spare. This novels point of view is a frame story that is told in the first person, from the narrators limited point of view as a visitor unfamiliar with Stratified and Ethan Frame.

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!

order now

However, most of the book is written in the third person limited, in which the narrator accesses Ethane thoughts but not those of the other characters. The genre of his novel which is a tragic romance does make a difference to whoever is reading the book, for not everyone has the same taste in literature. The themes and motifs are also a very important part of appeal to a novel for they give an atmosphere to the story being told. On the other hand, the literary parts used in the novel Of Mice and Men are different from those of Ethan From.

On the same topic, the setting of this novel is taken place South of Soled, California around the sass. This novel is told from the point of view of a third-person omniscient narrator, who can access the point Of view Of any hearted as required by the narrative. This novels tone is sentimental, tragic, doomed, fatalistic, rustic, moralistic, and comic. The genre of this novel is fictional and tragic. The characters in this novel have a variety of personalities. For example, one main character George Milton has a very caring personality.

In one part of the novel, George says When his aunt Clara died, Leonie just come along with me out working. Got kind used to each other after a little while (Steinbeck, 40). For other reasons, many novels are more interesting than others which may be more appealing to one reader or more. Ethan From, a tragic romance which is set in a fictional, wintry New England town named Stratified, where an unnamed narrator tells the story of his encounter with Ethan From, a man with dreams and desires that end in an ironic turn of events.

The narrator tells the story based on an account from observations at Frame’s house when he had to stay there during a winter storm. Finding himself laid up in the small New England town of Stratified for the winter, the narrator sets out to learn about the life of a mysterious local named Ethan From, who had a tragic accident some twenty years earlier. After questioning various locals with little result, the narrator finally comes to learn the details Of Ethane smash-up when a violent snowstorm forces the narrator into an overnight stay at the From household.

On the same topic, the major conflict of this novel was when Ethane main fight is with his own conscience, as he decides whether or not to reveal to Mattie his true feelings. “Their evening together had given him a vision of what life at her side might be, and he was glad now that he had done nothing to trouble the sweetness of the picture” (Chapter 6). The climax of this novel s when Ethan and Mattie confess their love for each other and decide to commit suicide by sledding into a large tree.

The falling action was that Ethan and Mattie regain consciousness after crashing into the tree; Ethan takes both of them in and cares for them into old age. His struggles are exacerbated by his surroundings such as Keenan his wife, the bleak Stratified landscape, and his home which often takes on an oppressive quality. Mattie was Keenan cousin and Ethane lover. This novel shows how even though Ethan and Keenan are married; Ethan loves Mattie more than he could possibly love Keenan. It’s bad enough to see the two women sitting here – but his face, when he looks around that bare place, just kills me” (Chapter 10). On the other hand, Of Mice and Men, a tragic fictional novel about two migrant workers in California during the Great Depression who were George Milton, intelligent and evil, but caring; and Leonie Small, an ironically named man of large stature and immense strength, but limited mental abilities come to a ranch near Soled south-east of Salinas, California to. George may seem like a mean guy for example in this quote: “Whatever we anti got, that’s what you want.

God mighty, if I was alone I could live so easy. I could go get a job an’ work, an no trouble. No mess at all, and when the end of the month come I could take my fifty bucks and go into town and get whatever I want” (Steinbeck, 11-12). But in another quote, it shows how much he cares for Leonie: “Well, I never seen one guy take so much trouble for another guy. Just like to know what your interest is” (Steinbeck, 25). For the same reasons, they hope to one day attain their shared dream of settling down on their own piece of land.

Lien’s part of the dream, which he never tires of hearing George describes, is merely to have soft rabbits on the arm, which he can take care of. George protects Leonie from himself by telling him that if he gets into trouble he won ;t let him “tend them rabbits”; they are running from their previous job in Weed where they were run out of town after Lien’s love of stroking soft things which resulted in an accusation of attempted rape when he touched a young woman’s dress. Furthermore, at the ranch, the dream appears to move closer to reality.

Candy, the aged, one-handed ranch-hand, even offers to pitch in with Leonie and George so they can buy the farm by the end of the month. The dream rashes when Leonie accidentally kills the young and attractive wife of Curler, the ranch owner’s son, while trying to stroke her hair. A lynch mob led by Curler gathers. George, realizing he is doomed to a life of loneliness and despair like the rest of the migrant workers, and wanting to spare Leonie a painful death at the hands of the vengeful and violent Curler, shoots Leonie in the back of the head before the mob can find him.

The shot occurs while Leonie is distracted by one last retelling of the dream. For other reasons, Of Mice and Men is really a book that relates more to the unman society rather than to people in specifics such as relationships. Although there is friendship it does not correlate with Ethan Bromes relationship between Ethan and Mattie. Steinbeck book would be more suitable for the kind of person that enjoys a thriller, while Wharton book is more for the person who enjoys a tragic romance.

All in all, although Ethan From was a tragic romance and may have some action, Steinbeck Of Mice and Men would be a better novel to read. It has more adventure, tragedy, and a little bit of relationship. The novel has a mix of tones that do not bore the reader. More importantly, the atmosphere is a little violent, but it is just what the reader needs to keep him/her on the edge Of his/her seat.


I'm Belinda!

Would you like to get a custom essay? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out